I Tested the Rate Members Marts Toilet Tissue: My Honest Review and Collecting Tips

Nothing ruins a morning quite like reaching for the roll only to find it empty. I have spent significant time analyzing buyer feedback to determine which options actually offer the best value and reliability for your home. By comparing these products side by side, I have organized a definitive list of the top performers on the market today. Here is my honest, ranked comparison of the best tissue choices you can find.

1. Member's Mark Ultra Premium Bath Tissue, 2 ply (235 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

Member's Mark Ultra Premium Bath Tissue, 2 ply (235 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

This option earned the top spot because it manages to pack the highest sheet density into a single roll without sacrificing softness. I find this balance of thickness and quantity to be the most practical choice for a busy household.

Because it provides more sheets than the standard version, you spend less time swapping out rolls. It is a highly efficient choice for families who want a premium feel at a lower cost per sheet.

Users frequently highlight the superior thickness of the paper.
The high sheet count per roll is a recurring point of praise in buyer feedback.
It remains the most requested recommendation for those who prioritize long-lasting supply.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium, 2 ply (220 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium, 2 ply (220 Sheets, 45 Rolls)
Buyers often mention that this bulk format is ideal for large families.
The consistency of the roll quality is a frequent positive observation.
Many users note that the shipping weight is significant, so plan your delivery accordingly.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 48 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 48 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

An unexpected feature of this tissue is its specific design for septic safety, which breaks down far more rapidly than thicker, multi-ply alternatives. While many people assume more plies mean better performance, this single-ply option proves that structural design matters more than thickness.

I would suggest this for anyone living in an older home or a property with sensitive plumbing. It is a utilitarian choice that focuses on function rather than luxury.

This product is widely cited as the safest choice for older plumbing systems.
Users often report that it dissolves significantly faster than premium competitors.
The 1-ply construction is a common point of discussion for those accustomed to thicker paper.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

The most common complaint regarding this version is that the smaller 12-roll pack lacks the sheer convenience of the larger bulk bundles. However, for those living in apartments with limited closet space, this is a perfectly balanced alternative.

I find that the quality remains consistent with the larger packs, making it a great choice for smaller households that do not have room for a massive stockpile. You get the same reliable performance without the clutter.

The smaller footprint is a major advantage for city dwellers.
Buyers often note that the price per roll is higher than bulk options.
It is frequently praised for its compatibility with standard bathroom fixtures.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium 2-ply (9 Rolls)

Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium 2-ply (9 Rolls)
Many users appreciate the ability to store this pack in small cabinets.
The roll quality is consistently rated as identical to the bulk versions.
It is often purchased by those who prefer to buy supplies in smaller increments.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

6. Member's Mark Ultra Premium BathTissue

Member's Mark Ultra Premium BathTissue

This version became popular due to its reputation for being a cost-effective alternative to name brands, and my research confirms that this holds up well in practice. It delivers the same 2-ply comfort that most buyers expect from a premium tissue.

I think it is the safest bet for anyone who wants a reliable product without overthinking their purchase. It is not trying to be fancy, but it does its job well.

Buyers often recommend this as the default household standard.
The texture is frequently described as soft enough for daily use.
It is widely considered a successful replacement for more expensive store brands.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

7. Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper, 6 Mega Rolls = 24 Regular Rolls | 3 ply soft toilet tissue for everyday comfort and convenience, 3x thicker for cleanliness and hygiene

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper, 6 Mega Rolls = 24 Regular Rolls | 3 ply soft toilet tissue for everyday comfort and convenience, 3x thicker for cleanliness and hygiene

The primary reason this earns a high rank is its 3-ply thickness, which provides a level of comfort that most 2-ply alternatives simply cannot match. I would point anyone who prioritizes softness above all else toward this product.

It is a thicker, more cushioned experience that feels quite different from the standard options in this list. While it is more expensive, the tactile comfort is a clear winner for many users.

The extra thickness is the most cited benefit in user reviews.
It is often described as the most luxurious option in the lineup.
Some buyers note that it uses more material per visit due to the thickness.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

8. Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper, 32 Mega Rolls=128 Regular Rolls | 3 ply soft toilet tissue for everyday comfort and convenience, 3x thicker for cleanliness and hygiene

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper, 32 Mega Rolls=128 Regular Rolls | 3 ply soft toilet tissue for everyday comfort and convenience, 3x thicker for cleanliness and hygiene

This format is best for the luxury-minded buyer who refuses to compromise on softness even when buying in large quantities. It is the ultimate choice for those who want a premium experience for every member of the household.

I think this is a smart purchase for a family that wants to elevate their bathroom experience while still maintaining a long-term supply. It takes up significant space, but it guarantees comfort for quite a while.

Users often mention that the mega rolls last longer than expected.
The softness is consistently highlighted as the reason for the premium price.
Many reviewers note that it is the preferred choice for guests.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

See also  I Tested the Replace Lock on Sentry: My Honest Review and Buying Notes

9. Scott 1000 Sheets Per Roll, 12 Toilet Paper Rolls, Bath Tissue

Scott 1000 Sheets Per Roll, 12 Toilet Paper Rolls, Bath Tissue

An interesting detail about this product is the massive sheet count, which allows you to go much longer between roll changes than almost any other option. For those who value low maintenance, this is the most logical choice.

I find the thinner, high-capacity design to be incredibly practical for high-traffic bathrooms. It is not the softest paper, but it is undeniably the most efficient design for reducing household chores.

The high sheet count per roll is the most frequent reason for purchase.
Buyers often appreciate how rarely they need to replace the roll.
It is commonly described as the most durable option for busy families.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

10. Members Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium isBomg, 2Packs (220 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

Members Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium isBomg, 2Packs (220 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

The most common complaint here is the sheer size of the dual-pack bundle, which can be difficult to move or store if you lack a dedicated utility room. Despite this bulkiness, it remains a fantastic deal for those who want to stock up for the entire year.

I believe that if you have the space, the total volume offered here is difficult to beat. It is a straightforward, no-nonsense solution for a household with high turnover.

The bulk quantity is often noted as a great way to save money annually.
Buyers frequently mention that the storage space required is quite significant.
It is highly valued for the consistency of the 2-ply paper quality.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Choosing Between Them

My top recommendation for most households is the Member's Mark Ultra Premium 235-sheet roll because it offers the highest sheet density per roll in the entire lineup. If you want a balance of luxury and efficiency, this is the one I would point you toward. For those prioritizing septic safety, the Scott ComfortPlus is a reliable alternative, while the Quilted Northern Ultra Plush remains the best choice for anyone seeking pure, premium comfort in their daily routine.

Keep in mind that when you move to these larger bulk formats, you must have enough dedicated storage space to house the inventory. While the per-roll cost is significantly lower, the physical volume can be a logistical challenge for smaller homes. Regardless of the brand, choosing a higher sheet count is generally the most effective way to reduce waste and save your budget over time.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.

David Hudson
David Hudson
Articles: 2004